21 Divine & Dreamy Cream Pie Recipes for Every Craving

Prepare to be enchanted! We’re diving headfirst into the glorious world of cream pies with our hand-picked collection of ‘21 Divine & Dreamy Cream Pie Recipes for Every Craving.’ Who could resist the sheer delight of a classic, old-fashioned cream pie? Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion, looking for the perfect holiday dessert, or simply indulging your sweet tooth, these luxurious creations are guaranteed to impress. Each pie is a masterpiece, typically crafted with a rich, velvety custard or pudding base, generously crowned with luscious, fluffy whipped cream, and often enhanced with delightful toppings.

Cream pies are the epitome of comfort and elegance, offering a symphony of textures and flavors in every bite. From crunchy crusts to silky fillings and airy toppings, they are a true testament to the art of dessert making. You’ll also love exploring more sweet treats with our additional roundups, including 15 Popular Easy Cream Pies You’ll Love and these 12 Delectable Pies for the Holidays! These collections ensure you’re always ready with a show-stopping dessert for any gathering.

The Irresistible Allure of Cream Pies

In my humble opinion, no cream pie is complete without a generous mountain of fresh whipped cream piled high! It’s the delightful cloud that transforms a simple dessert into an extraordinary experience. But the magic doesn’t stop there. The foundation of any great cream pie is its crust, which can range from a buttery, traditional pastry to a creative blend of crushed graham crackers, cookies, or even nuts. This versatility allows for endless flavor combinations and textures.

Beyond the core components, cream pies offer a canvas for creativity. Embellishments like toasted nuts, fresh fruit, rich caramel drizzles, delicate chocolate curls, sweet syrups, or colorful candies can elevate your pie to an even higher level of deliciousness and visual appeal. This curated list features some of the best heavenly dessert pie recipes that will make you go absolutely “ga-ga.” Get ready to discover your new favorite!

Explore Our Top Cream Pie Selections!

1. No Bake Peanut Butter Chocolate Cream Pie @ Crazy for Crust

This No-Bake Peanut Butter Chocolate Cream Pie is pure dessert nirvana. Combining the beloved flavors of peanut butter and chocolate in a simple, no-bake format, it’s incredibly easy to make yet tastes utterly decadent. Your friends and family will undoubtedly shower you with praise for bringing this heavenly treat to the table.

2. Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie @ The Baking ChocolaTess

Discover the delight of this dreamy Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie. It’s wonderfully creamy and rich with peanut butter flavor, yet perfectly balanced without being overpowering. The addition of light, airy whipped cream contributes a irresistible lightness and extra creaminess that makes this one of our most popular and delicious pie recipes.

3. Mexican Chocolate Cream Pie @ Handle the Heat

Experience a unique twist with this Mexican Chocolate Cream Pie. It features a wonderfully buttery yet crunchy crust that perfectly complements the thick, luscious chocolate filling infused with a hint of spice. Topped with a cloud-like, airy topping, this pie delivers an unforgettable flavor profile that’s both comforting and exciting.

4. Cookies and Cream Chocolate Pudding Pie @ This Gal Cooks

Simplicity meets sensational flavor in this Cookies and Cream Chocolate Pudding Pie. Made with just six common ingredients – a pie crust, Cool Whip, chocolate pudding, chocolate sandwich cookies, milk, and salted caramel sauce – it’s an incredibly easy dessert to assemble. The harmonious blend of creamy pudding and crunchy cookies creates a textural delight everyone will adore.

5. Vanilla Coconut Banana Cream Pie @ Lemon Sugar

Prepare to be impressed by this sky-high Vanilla Coconut Banana Cream Pie. Featuring a smooth vanilla filling layered with fresh bananas and topped with fragrant toasted coconut, this easy-to-make pie is a tropical dream. Its impressive height and exquisite flavor make it a showstopper for any gathering or a delightful everyday treat.

6. Bailey’s Mint Chocolate Pie @ Grandbaby Cakes

Indulge in the absolutely decadent Bailey’s Mint Chocolate Pie. This dessert is a perfect harmony of minty freshness, rich creaminess, and deep chocolate flavor. With a hint of Irish cream liqueur, it’s the ideal treat to celebrate St. Patrick’s Day or any occasion that calls for an indulgent and sophisticated dessert.

7. Dark Chocolate Silk Pie! It’s Delectable! @ The Baking ChocolaTess

Step aside, Willy Wonka! This Dark Chocolate Silk Pie is a luxurious fantasy come to life. Be warned: this pie is so unbelievably smooth, intensely chocolatey, and utterly delectable, it’s almost criminal. Its rich, silken texture and profound dark chocolate flavor will captivate any chocolate connoisseur.

8. Pumpkin Cream Pie with Candied Walnuts @ A Spicy Perspective

Embrace the flavors of autumn with this Pumpkin Cream Pie, perfectly complemented by crunchy candied walnuts. This pie offers a creamy, spiced pumpkin filling that’s lightened and enriched, making it a wonderful alternative to traditional pumpkin pie. The candied walnuts add a delightful texture and extra layer of sweetness, making it a standout dessert for fall festivities.

9. Strawberry and Cream Pie @ Deliciously Sprinkled

This No-Bake Strawberry and Cream Pie is a refreshing and effortlessly elegant dessert. Filled with an abundance of fresh, juicy strawberries and a light, creamy base, it’s a perfect choice for spring or summer gatherings. Its ease of preparation and vibrant flavor make it one of our absolute favorite dessert pie recipes.

10. Chocolate Cream Pie @ Tide & Thyme

This inviting Chocolate Cream Pie comes together with remarkable ease, requiring no fussing with crust rolling or crimping. A simple Oreo crust is generously filled with a rich, decadent chocolate custard, which then chills to perfection. It takes less than 20 minutes to assemble, and the bittersweet chocolate custard filling is wonderfully balanced, not overly sweet. Topped with a cloud of fluffy homemade whipped cream just before serving, it’s a truly irresistible classic.

11. Best Banana Cream Pie @ Chew Out Loud

Prepare for what might just be the best banana cream pie recipe you’ll ever taste. This rendition features a perfectly flaky crust, a wonderfully rich and velvety custard, and an abundance of fresh, ripe bananas. It’s a harmonious blend of sweet, creamy, and utterly irresistible textures and flavors that define a truly classic dessert.

12. Bramley Apple & Caramel Cream Pie @ Supergolden Bakes

This Bramley Apple & Caramel Cream Pie redefines the concept of homemade apple pie. An American-style “mile high” apple pie, it boasts a crisp, buttery pie crust filled with tender Bramley apples and luscious caramel, then crowned with a creamy topping. It’s truly the best homemade apple pie from scratch, especially when served warm with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.

13. Mae Dawson’s Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie @ Thibeault’s Table

Experience a taste of tradition with Mae Dawson’s Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie. While utterly delicious on its own, this classic regional pie reaches new heights with the addition of fluffy whipped cream and a sprinkle of toasted coconut. These extra touches provide the crowning glory, enhancing its comforting sweetness and creamy texture.

14. Black Bottom Banana Cream Pie @ Heather Likes Food

This Black Bottom Banana Cream Pie is a dream come true for banana and chocolate lovers. It features a rich chocolate ganache base that perfectly complements the creamy banana filling, creating an unforgettable dessert experience. The combination of sweet bananas and deep chocolate makes it the ultimate banana chocolate delight.

15. Pumpkin Chip Cream Pie @ Let’s Dish

This Pumpkin Chip Cream Pie is unbelievably easy to make, literally taking about five minutes to whip up – perhaps a little longer if you opt for a homemade graham cracker crust. It’s crucial to use mini chocolate chips here, as they provide just the right amount of chocolatey goodness that pairs exquisitely with the creamy pumpkin filling and a dollop of whipped cream. YUM!

16. Peanut Butter Cream Pie @ The Candid Appetite

This delightful Peanut Butter Cream Pie, adapted from Joy the Baker’s second cookbook, “Homemade Decadence,” is a nostalgic treat that will transport you back to childhood. Its rich, creamy peanut butter filling and luscious texture make it an instant classic, perfect for satisfying your sweet cravings with a touch of comfort.

17. Twinkies Banana Cream Pie @ Kleinworth & Co.

Prepare for a whimsical treat with this Twinkies Banana Cream Pie, an easy no-bake dessert bursting with your favorite childhood snack. This recipe features a crust made from crushed Twinkies, a creamy banana filling, and a delightful topping of slivered almonds and toasted coconut. It’s an easy dessert recipe you’ll find yourself making again and again.

18. Chocolate Peanut Butter Banana Cream Pie @ Fiesta Friday

This Chocolate Peanut Butter Banana Cream Pie combines an incredible medley of flavors: rich chocolate, savory peanut butter, sweet banana, and creamy vanilla pudding, all topped with whipped cream. Every single bite is designed to satisfy all your cravings at once, delivering a truly harmonious and indulgent experience.

19. Creamy Key Lime Pie @ Unconventional Baker

For those seeking a healthier indulgence, this Creamy Key Lime Pie offers a delightfully wholesome vegan alternative. It’s not only gluten-free and vegan but also paleo and refined sugar-free, proving that healthy can be incredibly delicious. Enjoy the classic tangy and creamy key lime flavor without compromise.

20. Samoa Coconut Cream Pie @ Sift & Whisk

Get ready to dig into a slice of pure chocolate-caramel and coconut yumminess with this Samoa Coconut Cream Pie. Inspired by the beloved Girl Scout cookie, this pie captures all the iconic flavors in a creamy, dreamy dessert format. It’s a perfect treat for fans of the classic cookie looking for a new way to enjoy its rich flavors.

21. Butterscotch Cream Pie @ Flour Arrangements

This indulgent Butterscotch Cream Pie brings together a crisp chocolate crust, a rich and thick ganache layer, sweet butterscotch pudding, and airy whipped cream for an unforgettable dessert. The layers combine to create a symphony of textures and flavors, making it one of our absolute favorite delicious pie recipes.

22. Extreme Reese’s Peanut Butter No-Bake Pie @ The Slow Roasted Italian

This Extreme Reese’s Peanut Butter No-Bake Pie is a dream come true for peanut butter and chocolate enthusiasts. It starts with a rich chocolate brownie base, packed with Snickers bites for extra crunch and caramel chewiness. Then, it’s generously loaded with peanuts and ooey-gooey caramel sauce, creating layers of flavor and texture. Finally, it’s perfectly topped with a fluffy nougat frosting, more candy bites, and a luxurious drizzle of milk chocolate ganache. This is truly a Snickers and Reese’s lover’s ultimate dessert fantasy!

23. Luscious Lemon Sour Cream Pie! @ The Baking ChocolaTess

Our Luscious Sour Cream Lemon Pie is a perfect storm of sweet, tart, and tangy lemon flavor, all encased in a rich and creamy filling. This lemon pie is perfectly suited for spring or summer, with its bright, sunshine-like color. It’s so visually stunning and deliciously vibrant, jaws will drop and there will be serious, serious drooling. *drool* (Told ya!) It truly is one of our best dessert pie recipes.

The Ultimate Collection of Cream Pies!

There you have it – a magnificent collection of 21 (and a bonus 2!) dreamy cream pies designed to make you go absolutely “ga-ga.” Each recipe offers a unique journey of flavors and textures, promising a delightful experience for every palate. Whether you’re a fan of rich chocolate, tangy fruit, or creamy peanut butter, there’s a cream pie here that will capture your heart. These pies are not just desserts; they’re celebrations in a slice, perfect for sharing with loved ones or savoring on your own.

More Irresistible Dessert Roundups to Explore!

If you’ve enjoyed this delightful journey through the world of cream pies, you’ll be thrilled to discover more of our curated dessert collections. Expand your baking repertoire and find even more sweet inspiration with these fantastic roundups:

• 15 Popular Easy Cream Pies You’ll Love! – Dive deeper into the realm of simple yet sensational cream pie recipes.
• 20 Delightfully Gooey Chocolatey S’more Desserts – Perfect for campfire cravings or cozy nights in.
• 15 Decadent Chocolate Covered Passions for Your Valentine’s Day – Indulge in rich chocolatey treats ideal for romance.
• 10 Dreamy Valentine Desserts – Find the perfect sweet ending for your romantic celebrations.
• 20 Heavenly Layered Desserts! – Discover beautiful and delicious multi-layered creations that are sure to impress.